This post may contain affiliate links. Click here for my affiliate disclosure. Thanks for helping me feed (haha...get it..."feed"...nevermind) my ice cream addiction (and support my site so I can keep giving you free recipes).
Recipe updated 12/8/15.
Yes, I’ve already posted a buckeye recipe. While it’s really good, I’ve learned things about baking and cooking with alternative flours and sweeteners since then, and I thought I could come up with an even better, more realistic candy. I do believe I have. While it’s not totally a buckeye (and cannot be without the aid of much powdered sweetener, which I do not have as it’s much more expensive than stevia and Super Sweet Blend), it is a totally passable substitute that fulfills my buckeye cravings. Better yet, it’s made from ingredients I had on hand and it contains a secret ingredient that you would never guess. Proof? My mom never batted an eye as she ate one of these when I made them earlier today… Don’t tell her they have beans in them, K? The idea of cauliflower in cake kinda weirds her out, so I imagine that beans in buckeyes would do the same.
I’m going to preach at you about the wonders of oat fiber again (click here for my first sermon on the subject). It’s a wonderful, versatile flour that is low-carb and low-fat. Yeah, you can use it in basically anything. OK, I’ll keep this sermon short, but you seriously need to go buy some oat fiber so you can use it to make these recipes. For a gluten-free option, click here.
I’m sure that you could layer the peanut butter mixture in the bottom of a 9×13 inch pan, pour the chocolate on top, freeze, and cut into small squares for something that looks like fudge. That would be easier. Not quite so traditional, but easier.
You can find this recipe in my cookbook, Necessary Food.
- ½ cup salted butter, softened
- 2½ cups natural peanut butter, as creamy as possible
- 1 15.5 oz. can Great Northern Beans, rinsed very well and drained
- ½ cup refined coconut oil, melted/softened
- 1½ tsp. vanilla extract
- ¼ tsp. THM Pure Stevia Extract Powder (or a powdered sweetener of choice, such as THM Gentle Sweet, to taste, for a more authentic flavor)
- 1 cup + 2 T oat fiber (use gluten free if necessary)
- Dash of salt, if needed
- Blend the first three ingredients together in a food processor until totally smooth (I use the food processor that fits onto my Ninja blender and it works great). Add the other ingredients and blend again. Refrigerate to let the dough firm up a bit. Once it's like firm cookie dough, scoop it out onto a wax paper-covered cookie sheet using a one-tablespoon cookie scoop. Freeze until solid. (If you didn't end up with a neat product by just scooping the dough out with a cookie scoop, you may wish to roll the dough into neater balls with your hands once it has chilled for a little while.)
- In a microwave-safe bowl (you could also do this in a double boiler), microwave the ingredients for the chocolate coating in 15-20 second intervals on the defrost setting of your microwave. Stir at each interval. Once the chocolate coating is smooth and combined, you're ready to dip.
- Dip the frozen peanut butter balls in the chocolate mixture one at a time (you can coat them all the way or leave the traditional dot at the top). Stir the chocolate every once in awhile so the sweetener doesn't settle to the bottom of the bowl. Once the chocolate coating is hard, transfer to a freezer-safe container and store in the freezer. Even when frozen, these buckeyes are bitable. Freezing keeps them nice and firm. You can let them set out for a few minutes before eating to soften up if you like. Yields approximately 60 buckeyes.
- If you have chocolate coating left over, add peanuts to make nut clusters and freeze spoonfuls on wax paper. When they're hard, store them in the freezer in a sealed container.
-If your natural peanut butter is pretty "dry", you probably won't need the full amount of oat fiber. For best results, make sure all the oil is stirred into the jar of peanut butter so it's smooth and oily. If your peanut butter is on the dry side, you may wish to add a couple extra tablespoons of coconut oil to the buckeyes.
-Use refined coconut oil, such as Louana brand, so you don't have a coconut flavor in these buckeyes.
-I would not suggest substituting anything for the oat fiber. You may be able to substitute another low-carb flour such as almond flour or coconut flour, but I'm not sure how that would taste (and it would definitely be more calorie-dense than the oat fiber). Oat fiber absorbs a lot of liquid, so take that into consideration. I know some people use protein powder as a substitute for oat fiber in recipes, but I haven't tried that and have my doubts that a cup of protein powder would taste good in this recipe (not to mention that it would be pretty expensive.).
Sweetener Conversion Chart
- I use the food processor with this Ninja kitchen set to make this recipe.
- THM Pure Stevia Extract Powder and Super Sweet Blend are the two sweeteners I used in this recipe. Both can be purchased from the Trim Healthy Mama online store.
- Oat fiber is one of my favorite low-carb flours these days. You can buy some here. For a gluten free option, click here.