This post may contain affiliate links. Click here for my affiliate disclosure. If you purchase items through my affiliate links, I receive a small commission but your price doesn't change.
Peanut-buttery goodness to spoon over the frozen custard I just posted today? You bet! Even better – it’s a Deep S for Trim Healthy Mamas!
Fats are great, but sometimes we overuse certain kinds of fats that our bodies don’t digest as well. Examples of fats that can be abused are cream cheese, nuts, heavy whipping cream, and cheese. There’s nothing wrong with those fats per se, but our bodies just don’t burn them as efficiently as they burn fats from coconut oil, eggs, butter, and meat. On the Trim Healthy Mama plan, recipes that use these efficient fats without the heavier fats and common sources of trace carbs (such as Greek yogurt and cottage cheese)Â are called Deep S recipes. When I was putting my cookbook together, I needed a category for my Deep S-style recipes, so I labeled them “Foundation Fats,” hence the name of the two recipes I posted today. (Click here to see my Foundational Frozen Custard recipe.)
I’ve been trying to focus on foundation fats recently, and my body loves them! I can tell that when I focus on Deep S rather than Heavy S foods, my metabolism kicks into gear. There don’t seem to be very many Deep S recipe options in the blogosphere, so I’ve been trying to fill the void by creating some new ones. I recently posted a Superfood Brownie Recipe that fits into the Deep S category, so if you pair those with my Foundational Frozen Custard and this peanut butter topping, you can have a brownie sundae – totally Deep S!
You definitely don’t need to keep this peanut butter topping just for Deep S, though. Feel free to enjoy it with any of my S or Fuel Pull ice cream recipes. (Click here for an index of my ice cream recipes.) There’s a peanut butter topping in my upcoming cookbook that uses natural peanut butter instead of defatted peanut flour in case you don’t have peanut flour. Up to one tablespoon of defatted peanut flour can be used in a THM: Deep S setting, and it’s a great way to get peanut butter flavor without a lot of the excess calories of peanut butter.
This yummy peanut butter topping is thick and spoonable, but you can add more unsweetened almond milk to make a thinner sauce.
Click here to browse all my Deep S recipes! I recently posted a single-serve Deep S brownie recipe that you might want to try.
Check out the Suggested Products section below the recipe to find links to the products I use and recommend!
You might also enjoy:
- Starting THM
- my picture recipe index
- my recipes indexed by THM fuel type, allergy info, and theme
- my Deep S recipes
- Your Healthy Ice Cream FAQs Answered

- ¼ c. defatted peanut flour
- 1 tsp. THM Super Sweet Blend
- ⅛ tsp. salt
- ⅛ tsp. glucomannan
- Dash vanilla extract
- -
- 6 T. unsweetened almond milk
- 2 T. refined coconut oil
- Whisk the dry ingredients.
- Whisk in the almond milk. Add the coconut oil and microwave in thirty-second intervals, whisking at each interval, until the coconut oil melts and everything can be whisked together smoothly. Serve.
- Yields 4 servings (do not exceed ¼ of the batch in a Deep S setting)
Suggested products:
- Defatted Peanut Flour (my favorite brand)
- THM Defatted Peanut Flour
- THM Super Sweet Blend – this is my favorite versatile sweetener
- Glucomannan (Amazon)
- Glucomannan (same brand as above, but from Netrition.com)
- THM Organic Glucomannan
- Cuisinart 1 1/2 qt. Automatic Ice Cream Churn – this is the ice cream maker I use!
Hi Briana! Is the chocolate ice cream used in the pictures for the foundational peanut butter topping one of your other ice cream recipies or is it the foundational frozen custard with cocoa powder added? It looks so incredibly yummy I want to try it!
Thank you!
Hi Julie! That was actually an okra experiment that didn’t quite pan out. 😛
Hey I love your recipes! I made the topping and put it in the freezer with my skinny chocolate, well I swear its too delicious for words!! I love this peanut butter topping !
Woohoo! I’m so glad you liked it!